Alan Wake 2, the latest release from Remedy Entertainment, has received warm initial receptions from both critics and players alike. Alongside praising the game’s elements, fans are increasingly asking one question: Is Max Payne in Alan Wake 2? The question gains traction because of the perceived similarities between the two iconic games.
This conspiracy doesn’t come as a surprise, given that Sam Lake is the creative mind behind both titles. It’s a thought-provoking query, leaving fans hungry for a definitive answer. So, let’s talk about that.
Related: Alan Wake 2 Review Scores Look Amazing
Is Max Payne in Alan Wake 2?

The short answer to this question is no, Max Payne doesn’t make an appearance in Alan Wake 2. Despite both titles in the Remedy Cinematic Universe, the character resembling Max Payne in Alan Wake 2 isn’t him.
So, you might ask, who is this mysterious FBI agent? The answer lies in the various roles undertaken by Sam Lake, Creative Director at Remedy Entertainment, throughout the years. To clarify this, let’s delve into the history of the characters brought to life by Sam Lake:
- Max Payne (DEA Agent in Max Payne 1)
- Alex Casey (FBI Agent in Alan Wake 2)
Sam Lake has been adding flavour to his games by portraying different characters, much like Stan Lee did in Marvel films. He was the original face model for Max Payne when it was released in 2008, a look that was entirely revamped in the sequel.
Max Payne in Alan Wake 2 might not be a reality, but Alex Casey is also played by Sam Lake. Consequently, from a distance, Max Payne and Alex Casey could easily be mistaken for the same person. Both are federal agents embroiled in dark, murderous plots. Alex even dons a long leather jacket at one point, nodding to Max Payne’s signature style.
Related: Is Alan Wake 2 Backwards Compatible?
Alan Wake 2 Cast: All Main Characters

For those curious about the presence of Max Payne in Alan Wake 2, a glance at the game’s cast could provide some insight. Because Alan Wake 2 isn’t just a good game — it also represents a peak of production quality, making it one of the most special projects to date.
Here are the main characters in Alan Wake 2 and the artists who portray them:
- Alan Wake — Actor: Ilkka Villi / Voice: Matthew Porretta
- Saga Anderson — Actress + Voice: Melanie Liburd
- Alex Casey — Actor: Sam Lake / Voice: James McCaffrey
- Tim Breaker — Actor + Voice: Shawn Ashmore
- Warlin Door — Actor + Voice: David Harewood
Among the list of main characters in Alan Wake 2, you’ll notice Shawn Ashmore’s name. He’s no stranger to Remedy Entertainment’s universe, having taken the lead role in Quantum Break, one of their previous titles. Though Max Payne in Alan Wake 2 isn’t a reality, it’s evident that Sam Lake enjoys collaborating with familiar faces in his projects.
Related: Alan Wake 2 Open-World: Is It Fully Open?
Conclusion
Wrapping up the topic of Max Payne in Alan Wake 2, it’s clear that while the iconic character doesn’t appear, the game is brimming with promise for the future. Looking ahead, eagerly awaited two downloadable content (DLCs) are in the pipeline, poised to expand on the narrative and gameplay.
Additionally, potential contenders for “Best Game of 2023” should watch out, as Alan Wake 2 is already carving out its space in that coveted list. However, consider the game’s high system requirements, which could limit its accessibility for some players.
All in all, though the nostalgia of seeing Max Payne may not be fulfilled here, the sheer quality and anticipated future content of Alan Wake 2 offer plenty to look forward to.
Author Profile

- My journey into the world of video games began at four, when I was first introduced to arcade machines in 1996. Over the past decades, I've been fortunate enough to witness the incredible evolution of gaming, as it has grown from a niche hobby to a thriving art. Today, I'm dedicated to creating content that celebrates all genres of games. We will talk about them at Player.me.